"EU PRE-ENLARGEMENT REFORMS » (Commission policy paper - 20 March 2024)

La Commission vient de publier un très général « policy paper » sur la préparation de l’UE à de prochains élargissements (voir ci-dessous).

Ce document est destiné à servir de guide et de base à de prochaines propositions et négociations.

Dès lors, il peut être utile de relever ou préciser dès à présent certains points ou certaines omissions dans ce texte.

La question principale concerne la séquence Réforme interne / Préparation à l’élargissement.

Il semble en effet opportun d’assurer que ces deux exercices soient menés de pair de manière à ce que tout nouvel élargissement soit précédé par une réforme adéquate de la « gouvernance européenne (1).

À cet égard, il est regrettable que soit passée sous silence la procédure en cours de révision des Traités officiellement déposée par le Parlement en Novembre 2023 - et sur laquelle la Commission ne s’est toujours pas prononcée.

JGGiraud 21/03/2024

NB les passages en rouge correspondent à des ajouts au texte inspirés par les considérations ci-dessus.

(1) voir aussi : https://www.lesamisdutraitedelisbonne.com/post/élargissement-et-renforcement-de-l-ue-le-grand-écart-de-la-commissionPRESS RELEASE20 March 2024Brussels

Commission prepares for pre-enlargement reforms and policy reviews

The Commission has today adopted a Communication on pre-enlargement reforms and policy reviews.

This document contributes to the ongoing discussion process about the internal reforms the EU27 is presently needing and will further need to make to prepare for an enlarged Union. It looks at the implications of a larger EU in four main areas - values, policies, budget and governance - laying the ground for the pre-enlargement policy reviews announced by President von der Leyen in her 2023 State of the Union address.

The EU must deepen as it widens. We must start preparing today for the Union of tomorrow and use enlargement as a catalyst for progress. All of Europe has overall gained from enlargement. It made the EU the world's largest integrated market. It opened trade and financial flows, thereby contributing to economic growth in the EU and in acceding countries alike, and strengthened the EU's weight in global affairs.

While reforms were necessary before, with enlargement they become indispensable.

Getting ready for a larger Union

Enlargement is in the Union's own strategic interest. While there are challenges, the benefits of a well-managed enlargement process span across various areas: geopolitical, economic, environmental, social and democratic. The EU has overall successfully managed previous enlargements, by adjusting EU policies ahead of accession, ensuring a rigorous accession process, targeted assistance and – where needed – transitions.

For these benefits to materialise, both the EU and aspiring Member States must be well-prepared, and the accession process must remain merit-based. This requires full and sustained political commitment and engagement, first and foremost from the enlargement countries, but also from the EU itself. By drawing on the lessons learned from previous enlargements and further improving our policies at 27, we are becoming better prepared for a larger Union. Notably, gradual integration has become an important element in preparing enlargement countries well ahead of accession.

Values

Upholding democracy, rule of law and fundamental rights is a cornerstone of the EU. It has to guide a deep-rooted transformation in enlargement countries. These values continue to guide a deep-rooting transformation in enlargement countries. The EU is strengthening its tools to ensure the rule of law is upheld consistently across the Union, beyond accession.

Policies

While challenges may appear, a larger Union broadens the many benefits of the Single Market. However, for these benefits to materialise for citizens and businesses, the enlargement process must be well-prepared.

Today's document focuses on:

Enhancing connectivity: A larger Union will strengthen physical connectivity, leading to lower logistical costs and smoother trade flows. It will ultimately bring tangible economic benefits to consumers and businesses. Much of this progress will depend on the availability of sufficient private and public investment and on regulatory convergence. The policy reviews may examine, for instance, how policy initiatives to enhance resilience through industrial breakthrough innovation could derive greater scale and support from Important Projects of Common European Interest.
Keeping up our climate and environment commitments: A larger Union has the potential to positively contribute to addressing climate change and biodiversity loss. Enlargement countries also have huge potential in terms of renewable energies and energy efficiency. Policy reviews would have to examine what new challenges can be addressed by the EU's climate and green industrial policy while safeguarding our ambitions and ensuring predictability.
Improving food quality and security: A key challenge of future enlargement will be to strengthen the EU's Common Agricultural Policy's ability to support a sustainable and competitive agri-food production model, while accommodating the needs of farmers and the variety of agriculture models. The policy reviews would examine the candidate countries and potential candidate's ability to apply EU legislation on direct farm support schemes and to implement the common market organisations for various agricultural products.
Creating the conditions for social, economic and territorial convergence: Membership of the EU brings tangible benefits to the economy, such as lower transaction costs, increased investment, intraregional trade, economic growth and stronger social rights. It also provides access to larger and more diversified financial markets, thereby reducing financing costs and providing consumers with more choice and lower prices. To address challenges linked to the governance of economic, social and territorial convergence policies within a wider group of Member States, the policy reviews would need to reflect on closing legislative and enforcement gaps, amongst other things.
Delivering strong security commitments, migration and border management: In an increasingly challenging geopolitical context, a larger Union would increase its role in world affairs and in multilateral settings – if it is able to act in a united, fast and decisive manner. This external unity and agility requires an underlying shared vision and a strong degree of shared analysis and views among Member States. Yet, a larger Union might, at least initially, bring a greater diversity of external policy interests and agendas which, however, should not undermine its unity and solidarity. The policy reviews should look into the Union's credibility and ability to act, which will depend on efficient decision-making through qualified majority voting in the Council and easier consensus making in the European Council.

Budget

The precise financial impact of enlargement will primarily depend on its timing, scope and on the result of the merit-based accession negotiations. In any event, enlargement should be factored into the reflections leading to the next long-term budget as well as to new own ressources . Future EU spending programmes should be developed with future enlargement in mind as well as enhanced control on the use of EU funds. In parallel, there will also be a need to look at how pre-accession tools can be fine-tuned to better prepare for accession and the transition towards participating in EU funds.

Governance

Since 2022, there have been reflections on EU institutional reforms. In 2023, the European Parliament has officially proposed a thorough revision of current treaties. The prospect of enlargement has given this debate a new sense of urgency. While the Commission has indicated its support to Treaty change, 'if and where it is needed', it believes that the EU's governance can be swiftly improved by using the full potential of the current Treaties, such as ‘passerelles clauses' allowing for a shift from unanimity to qualified majority voting within the Council in key areas. It will also be necessary to take account of the enforcement workload ahead, which is crucial to preserving the integrity and functioning of the European Union and its single market.

Background

A larger European Union holds significant political and economic potential. Maximising these opportunities will depend on our ability to identify, define and anticipate areas for improvement, and to set out a clear strategy on how to progress on the successive tracks of EU reform and enlargement.

Today's Communication kicks off the work on the in-depth policy reviews, announced by President von der Leyen in her 2023 State of the Union address. The Commission will carry out these reviews in early 2025. The reviews may take different forms depending on the sectors and will benefit from stakeholders' input on the specific impacts of a larger Union on EU institutional governance and on individual policies. Depending on the outcome of the reviews, substantive reform proposals ~~in individual sectors~~, including the preparation of Commission's proposal for the next long-term budget, could then be a second step in this process. Meanwhile, the development of the debate on Treaty reform as triggered by the European Parliament will be taken into consideration.

For more information

https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_24_1568

https://commission.europa.eu/publications/communication-pre-enlargement-reforms-and-policy-reviews_en